Get reliable rangeland science

Background: Theory predicts that plants can reduce their fitness in the presence of neighbours by allocating resources to root growth, in order to pre-empt resource capture. A number of studies that have tested this idea have done so by using experiments where neighbour presence is confounded with soil volume. Aims : To avoid confounding effects of neighbour presence and soil volume we adjusted these variables independently from one another. Methods: We grew Andropogon gerardii with and without neighbours, holding soil volume available to each plant constant, and compared plant performance with a treatment where both neighbour presence and soil volume were varied. We also grew plants with a quarter of the soil volume but four times the nutrient concentration to determine if changes in plant growth in response to soil volume are caused by access different levels of soil resources. Results: We found no evidence that plants adjust root growth to the presence of neighbour roots alone. We did, however, find a significant reduction in plant growth when soil volume was reduced. The reduction was overcome by increasing nutrient concentrations in the growth media. Conclusions: Our results suggest the effects of soil volume on plant growth are mainly due to changes in nutrient availability.