Get reliable science

Published studies relating erosion and productivity have been generally based on information derived from expert opinion on the extent and severity of soil erosion and on limited data on its impact on soil productivity, resulting in widely varying yield and economic loss estimates. In contrast, this report estimates the impact of soil erosion on productivity by collating, synthesizing and comparing the results from published site-specific soil erosion-productivity experiments at a global scale. Using crop yield as a proxy measure for soil productivity, this analysis uses the data from 179 plot-level studies from 37 countries identified in the soil science literature to calculate absolute and relative yield losses per Mg or cm of soil erosion for various crops, aggregated by continent and soil order. The results show that effects of past erosion on yields differ greatly by crop, continent and soil order. However, aggregated across soils on the continental level, absolute differences in productivity declines Mg-1 of soil erosion are fairly small. However, depending on the specific crop and soil, relative erosion-induced yield losses Mg-1 or cm-1 of soil erosion were two to six times smaller in North America and Europe than in Africa, Asia, Australia and Latin America. The higher losses in the latter continents are due primarily to much lower average yields, so that with identical amounts of erosion, yields decline more rapidly in relative terms. Studies using management practices as their experimental method to determine effects of present erosion showed much greater absolute and relative yield losses, which may be an artefact of the combined effect of erosion and variable management practices. Comparing the results of past and present erosion studies indicates that inappropriate soil management may amplify the effect of erosion on productivity by one or several orders of magnitude. Good soil management for effective erosion control and maintaining productivity, therefore, is imperative to meet the needs of the world's present and future population.